A question about Muk

[Fanta]

Is there a reason why Muk can't be found holding Black Sludge?
i know it's implemented since Koga has it on his Muk.

 

[Tornado9797]

Is there a reason why Muk can't be found holding Black Sludge?
i know it's implemented since Koga has it on his Muk.

I guess we're following Generation IV holding mechanics right now (8% chance of holding Nugget). If we were to follow the latest generation, then they'd have a 50% chance of holding a Black Sludge.

 

[Fanta]

I guess we're following Generation IV holding mechanics right now (8% chance of holding Nugget). If we were to follow the latest generation, then they'd have a 50% chance of holding a Black Sludge.

Ahh i see, ok so, how do we get that item in this game?
Also, Pikachu has a 1% chance of finding it holding a Light ball and this does not follow any game.
another example is clefairy which has a chance of 1% to be holding a comet shard and 5% moon stone and 50% leppa berry which follows B/W mechanics.

 

[Tornado9797]

Ahh i see, ok so, how do we get that item in this game?
Also, Pikachu has a 1% chance of finding it holding a Light ball and this does not follow any game.
another example is clefairy which has a chance of 1% to be holding a comet shard and 5% moon stone and 50% leppa berry which follows B/W mechanics.

In that instance, I guess the devs are kind of doing what they feel makes the most sense? I'm probably as confused as you are.

 

[Darkfire]

being confused is good
We havent done an amazing job with managing pokemon data atm so some stuff is all over......
We will work on fixing everything up at a later date

 

[Fanta]

being confused is good
We havent done an amazing job with managing pokemon data atm so some stuff is all over......
We will work on fixing everything up at a later date

Yea, i was just checking the data files since the wiki is a bit outdated, and i was confused by some of the numbers in these files.
So, i assume any problems similar to these shouldn't be reported, correct?

 

[Darkfire]

Yea, i was just checking the data files since the wiki is a bit outdated, and i was confused by some of the numbers in these files.
So, i assume any problems similar to these shouldn't be reported, correct?

Well......
depends on the urgency of it......
and maybe compile a list of discrepancies in anything not related to TMs(those are being worked on so anything there will be changed eventually....)

 

[Fanta]

Well......
depends on the urgency of it......
and maybe compile a list of discrepancies in anything not related to TMs(those are being worked on so anything there will be changed eventually....)

discrepancies between? i mean, What gen should the game use the mechanics of? Because i have seen a lot of these discrepancies, Such as in the : move sets/ held items /egg moves ....etc

Edit: i have been told before that some mechanics follow a specific gen while others follow different gens

 

[Darkfire]

discrepancies between? i mean, What gen should the game use the mechanics of? Because i have seen a lot of these discrepancies, Such as in the : move sets/ held items /egg moves ....etc

Edit: i have been told before that some mechanics follow a specific gen while others follow different gens

most things are gen 5(though we probably will update it eventually)

 

[Fanta]

Is there a way to get the ID's of the items, cause not all of them are listed in the wiki, for example, the 3 items mentioned above are not there, and took me sometime to find what they are.


Edit: Removed the double post.

 

[Darkfire]

here's the list via the source unless some new stuff gets added in the next day or so this should be the list as of next version

 

[Fanta]

here's the list via the source unless some new stuff gets added in the next day or so this should be the list as of next version

Thanks a lot