• ✨ ARCHIVE MODE ✨
    The forum has now been set to read-only mode, no new posts, resources, replies etc will not be possible.
    We recommend you join our Discord server to get real-time response: Discord Invite Link

Suggestions&Questions

Status
Not open for further replies.

Psyman2

Starting Trainer
Just wanted to throw a few things out that came to my mind

Donation
Will I be able to donate via sms in the future?
Since that's the way I usually donate money.

How close will this game try to be to the original? Are you just going to transfer the Gameboy version to the PC or are you taking some steps aside from the road like we've seen in Games like Super Pokemon Eevee

Minimap.
Could we add a minimap to ease players into the game? I have played through every game till crystal completely and wasted several hours with later editions and it was still hard for me at some points to find the right path.

Tweak to the difficulty.
The lvl of your enemies pokemon at your first encounter isn't 5 any longer but yourpokemonlevel-1 or even equal to your pokemons level
I always thought of this fight as a huge letdown after the red&blue fight lvl5 vs lvl5 which was a nailbiter if you hdidn't pick up the potion earlier .

Option to up the game speed.
This game seems to stick to the original which was an awful, awful, awful timewaster in terms of moving from X to Y or even training your pokemon (crystal edition kinda fixed this though by having slightly higher spawning rates).

No Animation.
When I click the option "no animation" I want no animation.
Yes, the intro gives me a nice lookaround and the animations are well done but I got sick of them after realizing that intro&outro were longer than the actual battle.

New characters.
The original series TRIED to implement some kind of quests or objectives like bringing letters to people.
Why stop there?
- Achievements not only show up somewhere as achieved but can also unlock rare items or give you hints where and how to catch difficult pokemon.
- Some people want to see something (special pokemon, items, arena badges, your mothers phone number) and give you stat enhancers for your pokemon in exchange or offer other services (not that kind of service, get your mind out of the gutter).
- more achievements overall

Text Speed
Pretty much self explanatory. Some things I want to read, some things I don't.
An option to raise the text speed would be nice. Alternatively show all the text at once when I leftclick.
Speed 3 doesn't cut it for me

Mom
There are two rooms in the house. One of them is the characters bedroom.
Your mother sleeps in the kitchen.
Pretty unimportant sidenote but an extra floor or room for her would be nice.

New Game
We've seen it in several games, the early one to implement this I can remember would be Advancewars.
After you completed your journey you are allowed to replay it with higher difficulty and several options added.

Level cap
Maybe for the new game (see above), maybe for everyone. Lvl100 always felt kinda weak.
In the original it was fun to grind your way up there but even at a young age I without any knowledge about the several small extras the game had I reached my pokemons maximum with ease after I won against the Elite Four and it only got easier in later editions.
Lvl999? Difficulty spikes when a pokemon reaches a certain level? New areas to explore?

Eastereggs
When we were young we thought pressing B really hard would keep the pokemon in the ball.
Or pressing B repeatedly
Or tweaking your gameboy
Or summoning a spawn of satan by drowning a virgin in goat blood.
Why not make our childhood reality?
Only to a certain extend of course, like raising the chance by 0,5 to 1% (absolute value).

Eastereggs2
More hidden items.
I always wandered around in red and blue "seeing" spots were hidden items were to be found even without the detector. In the end I found all of them except for two.
But I looked for them far more often then I was successful.
There is a lot of unused space in this game, it can easily be filled up with this and it would make the detector useful for once.

Bring me to the horizon
Block the view at a certain distance if it's not possible to walk to that point.. I often found myself walking in a certain direction because I thought there was an entrance/exit only to end up running into trees and feeling stupid.

Saves
Autosaves. nuff said.

Scrolling
Holding down A,W,S,D, up or down should do something. Clicking through the list can be enervating at some points. If I want to turn the music down for example.
I didn't know about the mousewheel option and to me it isn't the most obvious thing as far as I'm concerned.

Mousewheel
Toggle your view by using the scrollwheel

Action Delay
I just healed my pokemon.
I don't want to heal them again.
Please stop talking.
Even a 0,5 second delay would prevent this from happening far too often without any backlash (why would I even want to talk to the same person more than once?)

Music
When passing the music used to fade out before changing.
Would be a lovely extra.

Battlemusic
I turned the music down. The music is supposed to be turned down.
The music playing when I win is still the same volume as usual.

Option to disable autopause
"are you sure" if you click "quit to menu"

Scrolling
When I'm on top of a list and click up or W I should find myself at the bottom and vice versa

I especially want to point out the donation part.I'm a bit old fashioned and use neither online banking nor paypal so extra donation options would be nice.If it isn't neccessary because there are only very little people that donate than it can be implemented later.Or if someone has an idea of how I could throw some money at the developers with neither paypal nor ob feel free to tell me :)

Also a ref link would be nice. Someone said in some achievement suggestion thread that people like easy achievements because the... I only know the german word for it "Belohnungstrieb"... maybe the drive to get rewarded... whatever it's called, it works.
Also people would be animated to put the link to the game in their signatures in other forums.

I'll come back if I find something else :]

Sincerely
Psyman2
 
W

Whitney

Guest
A lot of these have already been suggested but some of these aren't really a top priority. Fixing bugs and filling in things that're current (such as move animations and sounds, more moves, abilities, natures and of course the next towns and routes) are more necessary.

Nillzz wants the game to be close to the original, but I believe he'll be changing a few things that were wonky and stupid in the original. What that entails, I'm not sure. You can actually change the text speed and difficulty under Options. The only thing there I can say is that I think the 2nd Difficulty option could be a little harder, but other than that I think it's fine. A lot of your suggestions are pretty personal and I feel like the staff would only consider or add things that're agreed upon on a wider scale and are more objective.

Not trying to sound rude or anything, I'd just like the staff to fix things and add what's necessary before they do any extra stuff. :)
 

Psyman2

Starting Trainer
Hey, it's called suggestions ;)

Yes, some of these things are personal, all of them are minor (which still means work, but it's quickly implemented) but trust me, especially the action delay (pokecenter) is something we all ripped our hair out about.
 

Darkfire

Administrator
Administrator
P3D Developer
I like the idea of removing the 100 lvl cap
if we let it go to 999 we will have to make the stats take four digits(if any of this is already possible then oops)
or maybe(don't know how this would work) allow the level cap to be moddable?
I am looking at the levels for my mod and I am worried that all of the pokemon will reach level 100 before I can finish the story :/(might or might not be an issue don't know for sure)
 
W

Whitney

Guest
I feel like a 999 lvl. cap would be kind of ridiculous. Because then their moveset would have to be stretched... or not learn any moves at all in that time, which would be kind of pointless. If the lvl. cap were to be changed at all, it'd need to be something a bit more reasonable. I doubt it will be, since Nillzz wants to keep the game as close to the original as possible, except for well, a few exceptions.
 

Darkfire

Administrator
Administrator
P3D Developer
I know that the movesets would be rediculous :/
even some sort of increase would be nice though(200?)
 

Psyman2

Starting Trainer
I never suggested it as being implemented in the original.
But in a Game+ or a modded version of the game, why not? Even five or six moves could be used.

By the way, a game tweak that'd help balance problems a lot would be an increase of hp by 10 to 20% because as far as I've seen it, status moves are worthless (has anyone ever used something other than sandstorm?)
 

AlessaGarnish

Dragon Tamer
Contributor
status moves are worthless
You can't say that status attacks like Sleep Powder (or attacks that makes the Pokemon fall asleep) are useless? You get the chance to attack the Pokemon for a few rounds without being attacked yourself. Such as Sand-Attack making them miss more.
 

Psyman2

Starting Trainer
yea, I blame that on my bad English.
What I actually meant to say was that moves that lower the enemies pokemons stats or raise your pokemons stats are worthless i.e. leer, tailwhip, etc.
 

AlessaGarnish

Dragon Tamer
Contributor
It depends who you're battling. You could use one Pokemon to spam Defense/Attack down attacks so you could easily beat the Gym Leader etc.
 

Psyman2

Starting Trainer
Uh, yes... or I could send the pokemon to sleep and kill it.

Btw, another idea: Challenge mode
Fight every arena master, one ofter the other

Different modes for fighting in general
- [opp.] pokemon +10lvl
- [opp.] pokemon +10%hp
- [opp.] pokemon immune to sleep/poison/burn/freeze
- Your Pokemon start with status poisoned
- etc.
 

DanielRTRD

Webmaster
Administrator
P3D Developer
Contributor
Elite Four
Donation
Will I be able to donate via sms in the future?
Since that's the way I usually donate money.
Maybe. Can you post a thread in the "website feedback" forum? And I will get back to you on that.
 

Psyman2

Starting Trainer
Also, the ability to create shortcuts.

For example "p" or "ctrl+p" for pokeball.

And adding to the idea of fighting modes

Areas, influence of natur (i.e. a sandstorm, accuracy drops by 50%), etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top